The 1900 census, Cullman County, Al. shows Beckie as having 9 children, 8 living at that time. Cullman County, Al birth registration show a child Elbert Butler, born and died April 1898. Howard Butler has accepted this child as Beckies 9th.
Compiled by Howard Butler, transcribed by Ginny Pitts, sources: 1880 census Shelby County, Al; 1900 Census, Cullman Cty, Al; 1869-1885 Marriages, Shelby Cty, Al, p 372; Kathleen Gable Bice; Cullman Cty birth records, April 1898.