| | Clarence Henry Cates 1907– | | |
| | | | | | James Robert Keating 1856–… Nancy Andelite Butler 1863–1935 | | | | Nicholas J. Keating 1824–… |
| | | John Wesley Butler 1840–1916 Nancie Ann Duke 1843–1905 | | | | James M. Butler 1813–1900 | | | | Christopher Columbus Butler 1786–1860 | | |
| | | James Peter Crawford 1770–… |
|
|
| | | William J. Duke 1811–1880 |
|
|
|
|
| | | Rufus Jasper Cates 1848–… |
|
|